My breeder, an older lady probably nearing 70, has an insane amount of birds and clearly makes her living from selling them, but I was very pleased with the care she gives them and the environment they live in and would recommend her highly to anyone. She lets customers drop in on short notice and is willing to give spontaneous tours of her bird barn and grounds. The birds' cages and bowls are very clean, they have lots of toys and indoor/outdoor space, and their pellets are good quality and supplemented with fresh food for a couple of hours each day (I came once when there was very fresh-looking raw veggies and fruits in each cage, and once when she was taking the still-fresh-looking leftovers out and bringing the bowls in for a good cleaning.) She has a full-time assistant, and the two of them spend the day making toys in the nursery and interacting with the babies when they aren't feeding or cleaning in the barn. The birds in the barn were all very friendly and interactive considering they aren't pets. The barn is well-constructed and climate-controlled with a lot of indoor cage space. The birds look healthy, mentally active, and not neurotic or anxious. The sounds they were making weren't the sounds of unhappy birds.
Based on my experience with her and her facility, I believe some people make money from their birds while still caring very much for them. Once she got talking about her birds, it was hard to get her to stop and she handled the babies very lovingly. Using my bird as an example of the outcome, I'd say she's fantastic at what she does. She also emails me for updates on Marvin, which says something about her. She told me it's never easy to say goodbye to a baby she's helped raise.
Is she a rare exception? Maybe. But she gives me faith that some breeders have a genuine love and respect for their birds. so I just can't generalize...but I do think it's important for buyers to see the breeder's facility before making a purchase, and they should watch and listen very closely.
In a way, we all exploit birds. They are meant to be wild and we have taken them into our homes to be our companions. There are forms of "exploitation" that are responsible and compassionate, and some that are not.





