Michael wrote:[When it comes to reading their pet's emotions, everyone seems to just make up whatever they want. Unlike observing behavior, this is largely based on the owner's emotions and not the animal's. You have no idea how many people I have encountered that say their bird likes, loves, or enjoys something (emotion) when the bird's behavior is actually quite the opposite. Same happens the other way when people say a bird hates them. Most of the time it's just the bird avoiding the person's actions (punishment) rather than some sort of emotion that the owner put on it. I disprove their emotional take by using some training and the behavior is solved. If you go on just pretending that it's all about emotions, you get nowhere with these situations. Meanwhile the behavioral approach works regardless of whether there is emotion behind it or not because it appeals to whatever unknown inner state the animal has because results are observable!
Ahhh, OK, yes, it is true that most people often read their parrots behavior wrong. I've also encountered myriad people misjudging a parrot's behavior... the most clear example been people saying their parrots were excited and interested in their surroundings when they go out and basing this belief on the fact that the bird remains on their shoulder perched straight, unmoving and looking around with a tense body (they compare it to a wide-eye kid in a zoo or a show) when, in reality, the poor thing is on high alert from being in a strange and potentially dangerous place but that doesn't mean the animal doesn't have emotions (in this example, anxiety and fear), it only means the human doesn't know enough about parrots in general and his/her own, in particular. But I doubt that treating animals like living machines is the answer that benefits the animal the most.