Thanks everyone, I guess I will try baking first because I really really do not want to part Harlie with the only toys she gets any enjoyment from, also I'm not really in a position to buy new toys/perches until next week anyway and I only have a couple of spare perches which is no good for two birds really.
Eurycerus wrote:Anyway I was informed by professionals around here that bleach does not kill the eggs/cysts but rather loosens the bond so you can better scrub them off. I believe baking is adequate but would want to check that.. I of course found out after I used natural found branches and had to calm myself down... :/ hopefully I did a good job scrubbing.
Yep, this concerns me as I have used natural branches too and I only soaked them in a mild bleach for an hour, soaked them in fresh water for about the same time, scrubbed them, rinsed them and thoroughly dried them out. I think I may bake any future branches we use too. Trouble is the sources I have checked are about 50/50 as to whether bleach is effective or not and I don't know the source of the giardia originally, if it is indeed that. I suspected it may be our water supply but the research I've seen suggests that they type of giardia that affects birds isn't in our water supplies unless there are droppings in the water, which I guess is a possibility that our water was contaminated somehow. If that was the case then how do I know its not still present and all my cage scrubbing will be a waste of time because its getting re-contaminated when I rinse it?
Andromeda wrote:I know for a fact you are very well educated on the efficacy of Flagyl in giardia in birds (~40 - 60%) so personally I would put up a fuss.
Absolutely, I think he should be looking into it rather than me trying to find the document for him but I understand why he does need to see the work, he cant just prescribe anything his clients ask for after all, particuarly when they don't have any experience of it.
Baylee4ever wrote:Panacur its a comercial name the actual product base is fenbendazole which means albendazole, fenbendazole and robendazole and ronidazole its the same...so i dont know why You say You wont give them panacur but You will give them ronidazole which is very similar... ALL THE PRODUCTS WITH 'DAZOLE' termination are related.... some are stronger than others but its really the same.
of course the drugs are similar but they are not the same, they all work differently otherwise we would just adjust the dosage in accordance with the problem, they all have side effects of course but again the side effects are different. For me the panacur is known to have a higher death rate than the others and if my vet wont consider using it ya know, it doesn't give me much faith. If you are talking about the merck veterinary manual as your source then I can already tell you it doesn't say anything specifically regarding disinfection (well the book might be more in depth than the online version, I will check at college) but it does talk about treating with the Metronidazole (which is an out of date drug choice for treating giardia as in 2003 it was only 40% effective, down 20% in 2 years!) and in some cases fenbendazole (which also has a low success rate, cant remember the exact figure until I find that damn pdf file again) but it blatently comments on deaths using the latter drug and says its not suitable for all birds and in no case should the treatments should be based on the dosage for other animals which is how dosage by weight is usually worked out.
Now no offence to you, I'm not saying I'm right and you are wrong but I'm basing my decision on reseach from multiple resources (books, repuatable websites and vets), I must have spent
at least 20 hours researching giardia alone and thats forgetting my initial research right at the start of all this.